As asset owners navigate geopolitical fragmentation, market uncertainty and mounting systemic risks, the relationship between financial returns and wider responsibility is being tested. Questions emerging from conversations at RAOEurope26 and subsequent contributions from delegates suggest that the debate is entering a more demanding — and potentially more productive — phase.
RAO Global Insights | November 2026
A familiar debate, but a changing landscape
For years, the investment industry has debated whether sustainability belongs within fiduciary duty. Yet perhaps the more interesting question today is not whether it belongs, but how it should be understood, prioritised and exercised in practice.
At RAOEurope26, held in London on 29 October and hosted by JPMorgan Asset Management, this tension surfaced repeatedly across discussions of capital allocation, governance, stewardship, systemic risk and long-term investment strategy.
The conversations were neither uniformly optimistic nor pessimistic. What emerged was something more useful: an acknowledgement that asset owners are operating in an increasingly complex environment in which traditional distinctions between financial performance and wider economic, environmental and social conditions are becoming harder to sustain.
Subsequent contributions from delegates have reinforced the importance of these questions.
If an asset owner's first obligation is to meet its financial commitments to beneficiaries, where does responsibility for the wider conditions in which those commitments must ultimately be fulfilled begin?
And, perhaps more importantly, what should that responsibility look like in practice?
Financial returns are the starting point, not the entire conversation
There is little disagreement that pension schemes and other institutional investors must meet their financial obligations. Investment strategies that fail to deliver the returns required to pay pensions cannot be defended simply because they pursue desirable environmental or social outcomes.
But this principle, while essential, does not settle the question.
A pension promise extending decades into the future depends not only on the performance of individual securities or portfolios, but also on the resilience of the economic and financial systems in which those assets operate.
Climate change, biodiversity loss, geopolitical instability, demographic pressures and institutional fragility can all influence the long-term investment environment.
Some of these risks are already reflected in asset prices. Others are difficult to quantify, poorly understood or distributed across markets in ways that make them challenging for individual investors to address.
This creates a fundamental tension.
An investment may be financially attractive within a conventional assessment period while contributing to risks that undermine economic prosperity over a longer horizon.
Equally, an investment presented as sustainable may fail to deliver adequate financial returns or meaningful improvements in underlying outcomes.
Neither possibility can simply be ignored.
The challenge for fiduciaries is to distinguish between sustainability considerations that are financially material, wider objectives that beneficiaries may legitimately wish to pursue, and activities that fall outside their legal duties or investment mandates.
Those distinctions matter. Fiduciary duty is not an unrestricted licence to pursue preferred social outcomes, but neither should it become an excuse to disregard risks simply because they are difficult to measure.
The hierarchy of responsibility
One particularly interesting question arising from the RAOEurope26 discussions concerns the hierarchy of priorities facing asset owners.
Should sustainability be considered only after expected financial obligations have been satisfied? Or is it, in some circumstances, integral to assessing whether those obligations can be met in the first place?
The distinction is more than semantic.
If sustainability is treated as a secondary objective, it may be vulnerable whenever markets become volatile, political pressure intensifies or short-term returns disappoint.
If, however, financially material sustainability risks are incorporated into investment analysis, risk management and stewardship, they become part of the investment process rather than an additional obligation competing with it.
But even this formulation leaves difficult questions unanswered.
How should trustees respond when a sustainability-related risk is potentially significant but its financial consequences are uncertain?
What happens when addressing a systemic risk requires collective action, while the costs of participation fall unevenly on individual investors?
And how should fiduciaries weigh near-term financial opportunity against longer-term economic resilience?
These are not questions that can be resolved by declaring sustainability either central or peripheral to investment management.
They require judgement, evidence, accountability and, importantly, a willingness to recognise legitimate differences between investment institutions.
The problem of the investment horizon
One of the industry's persistent difficulties is the mismatch between the time horizons over which investments are assessed and those over which some of their most consequential effects emerge.
An asset owner may have liabilities stretching across generations, yet its investment managers may be evaluated quarterly or annually.
Corporate management teams may face similarly compressed performance expectations.
Political and regulatory frameworks can change within electoral cycles, while climate, demographic and infrastructure transitions unfold over decades.
This creates the possibility that decisions which appear rational within one timeframe may prove damaging within another.
Long-term investors are often described as uniquely positioned to address these tensions. Their investment horizons, scale and diversified exposures may give them both the incentive and the capacity to consider risks that are less visible to shorter-term market participants.
Yet long-term ownership does not automatically translate into long-term behaviour.
Governance structures, performance benchmarks, manager incentives, liquidity requirements and the pressure to demonstrate immediate results can all constrain what asset owners are prepared to do.
Perhaps the more useful question, therefore, is not whether asset owners should think long term, but whether their investment arrangements genuinely enable them to act accordingly.
From commitments to capital allocation
Responsible investment has accumulated an extensive vocabulary of principles, policies, commitments and frameworks.
These have helped establish expectations and, in many cases, improved disclosure and accountability.
But the credibility of sustainable investing ultimately depends on what changes in practice.
How does consideration of long-term risk influence portfolio construction?
When does it affect the selection, monitoring or replacement of investment managers?
Under what circumstances should stewardship lead to escalation, changes in capital allocation or, ultimately, divestment?
And how can investors demonstrate that their activities have contributed to outcomes rather than simply documenting engagement?
These questions become particularly important when sustainability ambitions encounter commercial constraints.
For example, investors may recognise the strategic importance of financing energy transition infrastructure while remaining unwilling to accept unattractive risk-adjusted returns.
Similarly, they may acknowledge the economic importance of protecting natural systems without having sufficiently reliable information to translate environmental degradation into company valuations.
The answer cannot be to abandon financial discipline. Nor is it credible to assume that markets will always price every relevant long-term risk adequately or promptly.
What is required is a more sophisticated understanding of where investment incentives, financial materiality and wider economic outcomes align — and where they do not.
That includes recognising the limits of what individual investors can achieve.
Stewardship: influence or illusion?
Stewardship is frequently presented as the mechanism through which investors can reconcile financial responsibility with longer-term sustainability considerations.
Through voting, engagement and escalation, asset owners and managers can seek to influence corporate behaviour without necessarily sacrificing investment returns.
But stewardship also raises questions about effectiveness and accountability.
What constitutes meaningful influence?
How should investors assess progress when the desired outcome may take years to materialise?
And when does continued engagement cease to be credible?
For highly diversified asset owners, there is an additional challenge.
Certain risks, including climate change and the degradation of natural systems, may affect entire portfolios and economies. Their financial consequences cannot necessarily be avoided by selling one company and buying another.
This strengthens the argument for considering system-level stewardship: efforts to address risks affecting the functioning and resilience of markets as a whole.
Yet system-level stewardship introduces its own complexities.
How far can fiduciaries legitimately go in seeking changes to market structures, industry practices or public policy?
How can collective engagement remain consistent with competition law, investor mandates and differing beneficiary interests?
And how should success be measured when outcomes depend on the actions of governments, companies and many other participants?
These questions deserve rigorous examination, not easy assurances.
Who speaks for the beneficiary?
There is another dimension to fiduciary responsibility that deserves greater attention: the preferences of the people whose savings are being invested.
The investment industry regularly discusses what asset owners and trustees should do on behalf of beneficiaries. It less frequently hears directly from those beneficiaries themselves.
Yet their interests are not necessarily uniform.
Some may prioritise maximising financial returns within acceptable risk parameters. Others may place considerable importance on the environmental or social consequences of their investments. Many may hold both views, with preferences changing according to how questions are framed and what trade-offs are involved.
Developments such as pass-through voting, which can allow eligible asset owners to exercise greater influence over votes associated with their investments, raise further questions about the distribution of decision-making authority.
Could greater participation eventually help investment decisions reflect the preferences of ultimate savers more accurately?
Or might it create additional complexity, fragmented voting outcomes and uncertainty about the relationship between individual preferences and collective financial obligations?
There is also a distinction between asking beneficiaries what they want and determining what trustees are legally permitted or required to do with that information.
A meaningful discussion must acknowledge both.
Ultimately, fiduciary responsibility involves acting in beneficiaries' interests. Understanding those interests — without assuming that all beneficiaries share the same priorities — should surely be part of the conversation.
A more demanding definition of responsible investment
Perhaps the industry has reached a point where the most useful contribution is not another declaration of principle, but greater clarity about difficult choices.
Responsible investment cannot mean that every sustainability objective automatically takes precedence over financial performance.
Equally, financial responsibility cannot be reduced to maximising immediate returns without considering the risks, dependencies and obligations associated with longer-term investment outcomes.
A more credible approach requires investors to be explicit about what they are trying to achieve, why it matters financially or otherwise, what authority they have to pursue it, and how results will be assessed.
It also requires openness about trade-offs.
Not every sustainability-related investment will outperform. Not every engagement will succeed. Not every systemic risk can be addressed through portfolio decisions.
Recognising these limitations does not weaken responsible investment. It may be essential to restoring confidence in its practical value.
Continuing the conversation
One of the clearest messages emerging from RAOEurope26 was that the most consequential investment questions rarely lend themselves to simple answers.
The subsequent contributions from delegates have reinforced the value of creating opportunities to explore them beyond the confines of a single conference.
As RAO Global formalises the institutional investment network it has been building over many years into a structured, year-round community, these questions offer a natural starting point.
In particular, we would welcome perspectives on three issues:
1. Where should fiduciaries draw the line between financial obligations and wider sustainability responsibilities?
2. What practical changes would make long-term sustainability considerations more influential in capital allocation, manager selection and stewardship?
3. How can asset owners demonstrate that their approach to responsible investment is delivering genuine value for beneficiaries?
There will be differing views, and there should be.
The purpose of the RAO Global Network is not to manufacture consensus, but to bring together the people responsible for allocating, managing and advising on capital to challenge assumptions, exchange experience and identify practical ways forward.
Because the most valuable conversations are not necessarily those that produce immediate agreement.
They are the ones that change how we think — and ultimately, how we act.
Join the conversation
The RAO Global Network brings together asset owners, investment managers and senior industry practitioners for year-round dialogue, specialist discussions, member-informed insights and opportunities to connect with peers.
Join the RAO Global Network: https://network.raoglobal.org
RAO Global Insights | Responsible Asset Owners Global